Mental health costs: Young people bill $200 million a year to Medicare


The authors suggest school-based screening for mental illness would be a cost-effective strategy. Photo: Getty
Caring for young people with mild to moderate mental health issues is costing Australian families and the public purse $234 million a year, according to analysis from Deakin University.
This breaks down to $197 million paid by Medicare and $37 million in out-of-pocket costs for families.
In the main, these are the costs of young people accessing mental health assessment and mental health treatment plans from GPs â and for a limited number of Medicare-rebated sessions with a psychologist.
This is distinct from children needing treatment for severe illnesses such as bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and severe treatment-resistant depression.
Children who donât meet full criteria
Half these costs â about $100 million â are for services used by children who donât meet the full criteria of a mental disorder, and most were for âgeneral health-related servicesâ.
Director of Deakin Health Economics, Professor Cathy Mihalopoulos, said: âPeople with mental health symptoms might seek help from general health professionals, such as GPs or paediatricians, rather than
mental health professionals as they might not be eligible for specialised care via Medicareâs Better Access program.â
Research lead Dr Long Le, an Alfred Deakin Postdoctoral Fellow from Deakin Health Economics, said that children and adolescents âwith two or more mental disorders had the highest average annual Medicare costs of mental health services followed by those with depression, conduct disorder and anxietyâ.
The study analysed data from the Young Minds Matter Survey.
Are kids with ADHD getting proper treatment?
The study didnât look at outcomes, but it throws up some questions.
The researchers found that Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was associated with higher spending on medication and general health-related Medicare costs but with not mental health-related Medicare costs.
This means these children âmight be mostly seeing GPs or paediatricians and receiving medication for their ADHD rather than receiving psychotherapy from a psychologist or psychiatrist,â Professor Mihalopoulos said.
The researchers arenât suggesting that these young people arenât receiving the level of care they need because they are seeing their GP â as many trained GPs provide high-quality care â but rather, that âwe just donât know if they are seeing these well-trained GPsâ.
But compared to children with other mental disorders, âthose with ADHD tend to receive their care in the general rather than mental health specific systemâ.
Does this matter?
Medication is the standard treatment for what is essentially a brain condition.
But psychological treatments, âsuch as behavioural therapy, may help a child develop strategies and skills for learning and controlling their behaviourâ, according to the federal governmentâs health advice website.
Cognitive behavioural therapy is particularly helpful in adolescents with ADHD.
The ADHD Institute recommends âthat non-pharmacological interventions are focused on the individual with ADHD as they mature and become âagents of implementationâ in their careâ.
And thereâs some evidence that neurotherapy â a biofeedback technique that enables individuals to normalise their brainâs electrical activity and improve symptoms â can result in patients functioning successfully with medication.
So it remains unclear whether young people with ADHD (which affects one in 20 Australians) are getting the full suite of necessary treatment.
What the researchers recommend
On the face of it, $197 million billed to Medicare is a lot of money, but perhaps not so much given that Australia spends nearly $11 billion a year on mental health services, according to the Australian Institute of Health and Welfare.
Dr Le said the research findings showed the considerable financial burden for families with a child experiencing mental health issues and presented a strong case for spending on prevention strategies.
âMental disorders in children and adolescents are common, with one in seven diagnosed with a mental disorder and one in three with mental health symptoms,â Dr Le said.
âOur study shows that aside from the substantive impacts these disorders have on children and adolescents and on their families,
there are significant costs to Medicare and high out-of-pocket costs faced by the families.â
Professor Mihalopoulos said there is strong evidence that school-based screening and intervention for conditions such as anxiety and depression âare the most cost-effective interventions for prevention of mental disorders in children and adolescentsâ.
âWhat do we need to implement such interventions?â she pondered.
School interventions: Where are they?
School interventions have been the great hope for preventing anxiety and depression for years. So where are they?
The short answer appears to be that they are either a work in progress or theyâre not sufficiently, or at least demonstrably, evidence based.
In 2016, the Black Dog Institute published a paper about school interventions.
It noted that mental disorders in adolescence are the leading cause of illness and disability for young people aged 10 to 19, ahead of any physical disease.
âFrom a practical perspective, there is good reason to develop prevention interventions for adolescents that can be delivered through the school system as part of the mental health educational curriculum,â the authors wrote.
âThis is critically important because adolescents with mental disorders have very low rates of help-seeking (35 per cent), and only 30 per cent seek referrals for psychological therapyâ.
The question of evidence-based programs
Jennie Hudson is director of research, Professor of Clinical Psychology with the Black Dog Institute. In an email responding to questions, she told TND that âBlack Dog interventions for school-age children and teens are still in the research phaseâ.
Dr Hudson said Black Dog is running âa large-scale randomised controlled trial with up to 10,000 school students around Australia called Future Proofing, which delivers digital evidence-based mental health interventions to young people, and follows them up for five yearsâ.
One of the therapeutic components of this trial is an app called Sleep Ninja, which is based on cognitive-behavioural therapy principles and targets insomnia and depression symptoms in young people.
Dr Hudson said that one of the issues affecting interventions in schools âis the absence of guidelines or regulatory frameworks to guide this processâ.
She said the KidsMatter program, which ceased in 2018, went âsome way to address this, but for school principals and welfare staff it is really difficult to determine which programs are evidence-basedâ.
Programs might advertise as being based on evidence, she said, âyet the program or its components have never been evaluatedâ.
Dr Hudson said âit would be like attending a doctor for a medical condition like diabetes and given a new drug that hasnât yet been evaluatedâ.
Teachers have concerns about their own competence
Dr Hudson said teachers were generally open to supporting the mental health of their students, âbut they have concerns about their competence to provide mental health assistanceâ.
The lack of guidelines or a regulatory framework placed âan unnecessary burden on schools and teachersâ.
She said the delivery of evidence-based care is an issue across health but is âa particular issue in the mental health interventions spaceâ.
Black Dog is recommending some guidelines for the delivery of services to ensure they are evidence based.
Although about 3000 of the 27,000 psychologists in the Australian workforce are employed in school settings, Dr Hudson said there were âsubstantial variations in the ratios of psychologists to young people across different states and territoriesâ.
Access to clinical psychologists and evidence-based care also faces equity issues between public and private schools, she said.
Additionally, regional and rural schools may not have locally based psychologists and therefore face the added difficulty of relationship building and continuity of care with a âfly-in fly-outâ workforce.








