News World Reopening schools brings relief, but also coronavirus risks … and a different kind of test
Updated:

Reopening schools brings relief, but also coronavirus risks … and a different kind of test

Lea Hammermeister, a year 11 student in Germany, conducts a coronavirus test before going to school. Photo: The New York Times
Share
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

It was Lea Hammermeister’s first day back at school after almost two months at home, and she was already preparing for a test.

Not a math or physics test. A coronavirus test – one she would administer herself.

The 17-year-old high school junior entered the tent erected in the schoolyard along with some classmates – all standing 1.8 metres apart – and picked up a test kit.

She inserted the swab deep into her throat, gagging slightly as instructed, then closed and labelled the sample before returning to class.

It took less than three minutes. The results landed in her inbox overnight.

A positive test would require staying home for two weeks. Hammermeister tested negative.

She now wears a green sticker that allows her to move around the school without a mask – until the next test four days later.

“I was very relieved,” she said happily.

In addition to feeling safe around her classmates and teachers, who all tested negative, she feels like less of a risk to her grandmother, who eats with the family every day.

The self-administered test at the high school at Neustrelitz, a small town in northern Germany, is one of the more intriguing efforts in Europe as countries embark on a giant experiment in how to reopen schools, which have been shuttered for weeks and which are now being radically transformed by strict hygiene and distancing rules.

Restarting schools is at the core of any plan to restart economies globally.

If schools do not reopen, parents cannot go back to work. So how Germany and other countries that have led the way on many fronts handle this stage in the pandemic will provide an essential lesson for the rest of the world.

“Schools are the spine of our societies and economies,” said Henry Tesch, headmaster of the school in northern Germany that is piloting the student tests.

“Without schools, parents can’t work and children are being robbed of precious learning time and, ultimately, a piece of their future.”

In Germany, which last week announced it would reopen most aspects of its economy and allow all students back in coming weeks, class sizes have been cut in half.

Hallways have become one-way systems. Breaks are staggered. Teachers wear masks and students are told to dress warmly because windows and doors are kept open for air circulation.

Germany has been a leader in methodically slowing the spread of the virus and keeping the number of deaths relatively low.

But that success is fragile, Chancellor Angela Merkel has warned.

On Saturday, the reproduction factor – the average number of people who get infected by every newly infected person – which the government wants to stay below 1, crept back up to 1.1.

With still so little known about the virus, many experts say mass testing is the only way to avoid the reopening of schools becoming a gamble.

The school at Neustrelitz is still an exception.

But by offering everyone including teachers and students free tests twice a week, it is zeroing in on a central question haunting all countries at this stage in the pandemic: Just how infectious are children?

Evidence suggests that children are less likely to become seriously ill from COVID-19 than adults.

But small numbers of children have become very sick and some have died, either from the respiratory failure that causes most adult deaths or from a newly recognised syndrome that causes acute inflammation in the heart.

An even greater blind spot is transmission. Children often do not have symptoms, making it less likely that they are tested and harder to see whether or how they spread the virus.

The prospect that schoolchildren, well-documented spreaders of the common flu, might also become super spreaders of the coronavirus, is the central dilemma for countries looking to reopen while avoiding a second wave of deadly infections. It means that school openings could pose real dangers.

“That’s my biggest fear,” said Professor Michael Hoelscher, head of infectious diseases and tropical medicine at Munich University Hospital, who oversees a household study in Munich that hopes to shed light on transmission inside families.

Manfred Prenzel, a prominent educationalist and member of a panel advising the German government on its reopening, said children represent the most intractable aspect of this pandemic: Asymptomatic transmission.

A study published in Germany last week by the country’s best-known virologist and coronavirus expert found that infected children carried the same amount of the virus as adults, suggesting they might be as infectious as adults.

“In the current situation, we have to warn against an unlimited reopening of schools and nurseries,” concluded the study supervised by Christian Drosten at the Berlin-based Charite hospital.

The Robert Koch Institute of public health, Germany’s equivalent of the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention in the United States, found that children get infected in roughly equal proportions to adults.

Other studies, including two from China, suggest children may be less contagious than adults, possibly because they often do not have the symptoms that help spread it, like a cough.

Researchers in Iceland and the Netherlands did not identify a single case in which children brought the virus into their homes.

“The evidence is not yet conclusive,” said Richard Pebody, team leader for high-threat pathogens at the World Health Organisation.

His advice on school openings: “Do it very gradually and monitor the ongoing epidemiology very closely.”

That is easier said than done.

For now, Europe’s school openings are as varied as its countries.

Denmark opened primary schools and nurseries first, reasoning that young children are the least at risk and the most dependent on parents, who need to return to work.

Germany allowed older children back to school first because they are better able to comply with rules on masks and distancing.

France is opening preschools on Monday before phasing in primary and middle school children later in the month. High school students will keep learning remotely for now.

Belgium, Greece and Austria are all resuming lessons for select grades in coming weeks.

Sweden never closed its schools but has put in place distancing and hygiene rules.

Some hard-hit countries like Spain and Italy are not confident enough to open schools until the fall.

One precondition for any country to open schools, epidemiologists say, is that community transmission rates be at manageable levels.

Early evidence from countries that have led the way in lowering community transmission and opening schools looks hopeful, said Flemming Konradsen, director of the School of Global Health at the University of Copenhagen.

Denmark, after letting younger children back more than three weeks ago, announced last week that the reproduction factor of the virus remained below 1.

Older students will be allowed to return to school on Monday.

A class at Neustrelitz, Germany, last week. Schools are reopening in parts of Europe, but it comes with risks. Photo: The New York Times

Germany, Europe’s biggest country, announced last week that all children would see the inside of a classroom again before the summer break after a two-week trial run in high schools had not stopped overall transmission numbers from falling.

Officials hope the rise that was reported over the weekend was a blip instead of a sign that the loosening is already reviving the spread of the disease.

Many argue the benefits of opening schools – to economies, parents and the children themselves – far outweigh the costs so long as hygiene rules are put in place.

Disadvantaged children in particular suffer from being out, said Sophie Luthe, a social worker at a Berlin high school.

“We have been losing children; they just drop off the radar,” Ms Luthe said.

“School is a control mechanism for everything from learning difficulties to child abuse.”

But teaching in the time of a pandemic comes with a host of challenges: In the high school at Neustrelitz, roughly a third of the teachers are out because they are older or at risk.

There are not enough classrooms to allow all 1000 students to come to class and still keep 1.8 metres apart, which means at most a third can be in school at any one time. Teachers often shuttle between classrooms, teaching two groups at once.

At the same time, the virus is spurring innovation.

Teachers in Denmark have moved a lot of their teaching outdoors.

German schools, long behind on digital learning, have seen their technology budgets increase overnight.

“Corona is exposing all our problems,” said Mr Tesch, the headmaster in Neustrelitz.

“It’s an opportunity to rethink our schools and experiment.”

The New York Times