News National Boats sent to tackle Labor’s attacks on Medicare

Boats sent to tackle Labor’s attacks on Medicare

The government is looking to make asylum-seeker boats an election issue
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull says voters have a stark choice between stability and chaos on July 2.

In a tactical battle of scare campaigns, Mr Turnbull and Immigration Minister Peter Dutton have detailed recent asylum seeker boat turn-backs to proclaim Labor’s weakness on the tough policy. 

And the government has abandoned its usual secrecy to try to make its point.

• The Greens are gunning for Feeney
• Malcolm Turnbull takes on Q&A single-handed
• Shorten wedges Turnbull on Medicare

For what are claimed to be ‘operational’ reasons the government usually does not publicly acknowledge attempts by people smuggler boats to reach Australian territorial waters.

It neither confirms nor denies reports of interceptions at sea or the forced return of asylum seekers.

But faced with an increasingly effective campaign by Labor leader Bill Shorten claiming that a returned Coalition government would move to privatise Medicare, Mr Dutton stepped forward on Wednesday to admit his motivation was political.

He detailed the Operation Sovereign Borders interception of an “unseaworthy” boat containing 21 people, comprising 11 males, six females, three children and one baby, from Vietnam earlier in June.

An assessment of the consequent asylum claims concluded they were groundless and the passengers were returned to Vietnam by plane. Authorities were aware of another boat attempting to embark from Aceh in Indonesia.

Political motives

Mr Turnbull says the government has turned back 28 boats carrying 734 passengers. Photo AAP
Mr Turnbull says the government has turned back 28 boats carrying 734 passengers. Photo: AAP

The lifting of secrecy on the release of operational information about boat turn-backs was justified, Mr Turnbull said, because the public needed to be appraised of policy differences with Labor on border protection before polling day.  

The Prime Minister said in Cairns the Coalition government had turned back 28 boats carrying 734 passengers since coming back to government in September 2013.

“Labor does not have the willpower to do it,” Mr Turnbull said.   

While Mr Shorten claimed to have the same turn-back policy as the Coalition, the prime minister asserts any future Labor-Greens government would abandon the tough policy.

“We saw that with Kevin Rudd,” Mr Turnbull said, with a resultant 50,000 unauthorised arrivals.

“You have to love the Liberal Party central headquarters.” Mr Shorten said in response. “It is the break glass issue. Spread concern and say somehow Labor has a different policy to the Liberals when it comes to deterring boats. They should be ashamed of themselves … “

Is the Medicare “scare” justified?

Significantly, Mr Shorten stands by his claim that Medicare is in danger under a Coalition government.

While Tony Shepherd, former head of the Abbott government’s commission of audit, said he did not recommend privatisation, only an upgrade of its payments system, Mr Shorten says there was significant evidence indicating Coalition intentions.

AMA president Michael Gannon has said “there is absolutely no evidence at all that the Liberal Party has any intention to privatise Medicare.

Yet the Opposition Leader says increasing the proportion of private service provision within Medicare is the “thin edge of the wedge”.  

Labor is using it's Medicare "scare" campaign to rally labor voters. Photo: AAP
Labor is using it’s Medicare “scare” campaign to rally labor voters. Photo: AAP

Mr Shorten says the heart of Medicare is bulk-billing, a one-payment system. 

The Coalition tried unsuccessfully to impose a GP co-payment and has continued a freeze on GP rebates, which Labor now promises to abandon. The freeze will force doctors to charge their patients more to cover increasing operational costs.

“The heart of Medicare is making sure you can afford to go and see the doctor,” Mr Shorten said. “If the Liberal Party win the election on July 2, you will pay more to see the doctor. You will pay more for your medicine. You will pay more for tests. It means Medicare, as we know it, will be changed.”

The current scare campaigns are directed at undecided marginal seat voters. “Stop the boats” has traditionally been devastatingly effective in motivating usual Labor-leaners to cross to the Liberal Party.

“Protect Medicare” is designed to exploit distrust at Liberal promises and move the undecided to vote Labor.

Quentin Dempster is a Walkley Award-winning journalist, author and broadcaster with decades of experience. He is a veteran of the ABC newsroom and has worked with a number of print titles including the Sydney Morning Herald. He was awarded an Order of Australia in 1992 for services to journalism.

View Comments