Advertisement

‘Lives at risk’ as unis forced to pass weak students

Nurses around Australia are calling for better working conditions after a colleague was stabbed in Adelaide.

Nurses around Australia are calling for better working conditions after a colleague was stabbed in Adelaide. Photo: Shutterstock

Academics from two of Australia’s largest nursing faculties say weak students are being undeservedly awarded nursing degrees, potentially endangering public safety, an investigation has uncovered.

It revealed lecturers and tutors are grappling with a tide of academic misconduct and pressure from faculty managers to pass weak students, with many saying commercial imperatives are overtaking academic rigour.

ABC’s Four Corners program on Monday night identified significant pressure at Australian universities to pass underperforming students, many of whom are full-fee-paying internationals.

These uni degrees offer the best value for money
Rich kids skip Year 12, go straight to uni
Uni expels essay cheats

It also found some university administrators have turned a blind eye to rampant academic misconduct.

Academics from two of Australia's largest nursing faculties say weak students are being undeservedly awarded nursing degrees, potentially endangering public safety.

Academics say weak students are being awarded nursing degrees, potentially endangering public safety. Photo: Shutterstock

One senior academic who has taught at both the University of Western Sydney (UWS) and the Australian Catholic University (ACU), said on Monday night’s program that both universities were relaxing standards and ignoring plagiarism.

“There are students that are falling through the cracks, and yes, they could end up being unsafe practitioners,” she said.

“There are a group of students who I honestly believe … should not be graduating.”

A former senior figure at UWS nursing said the situation had become so dire it required industrial action.

“I believe that it’s the profession that has to stand up, they have to rise up and they have to tell the registering accrediting bodies, ‘stop what you are doing and increase the entry level’ … for entry into the bachelor of nursing,” she said.

“I don’t think the universities will do it because they’ve got a vested interest because of funding.

“So who’s left? Individuals can’t do it. The profession of nursing needs to do it.

“They need to stand up, they need to rise and say ‘stop what you are doing’.”

In a statement, UWS strenuously denied soft-marking was a problem: “UWS completely rejects the accusation that the standard of our nursing program is ‘falling’ and our nursing students are ‘weak and unsafe’.”

ACU said it had strict policies to manage academic misconduct.

Asked about ongoing concerns in the health sciences faculty about the pressure to pass students, a spokeswoman said: “No staff member has the right to direct staff to change grades.”

“There is a process to ensure every course and every unit is reviewed and assessed by formally constituted Faculty and School committees.”

The vice-chancellors of both universities declined requests for an interview with Four Corners.

Gap between ‘capabilities of students and academic demands’

A major report by the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption last week, Learning the Hard Way, reported widespread problems with soft-marking across the university sector and significant risks of corruption within institutions.

“There is a gap – at least in some courses – between the capabilities of many students and academic demands,” the report said.

“Students may be struggling to pass, but universities cannot afford to fail them.

Uni students working overseas don't pay fees.

“There is pressure for some international students to pass courses that are beyond their academic capabilities,” the Learning the Hard Way report says.

“There is pressure for some international students to pass courses that are beyond their academic capabilities, pressure on staff within universities in NSW to find ways to pass students in order to preserve budgets.

“When it involves sufficient numbers, the tension created by the student capability gap and the need to meet revenue targets becomes more conducive to corruption.

“Academics come under pressure to turn a blind-eye to problems caused by poor academic capabilities and actively play a part in allowing students to pass who should fail.”

Four Corners also broadcasted evidence of collusion involving some offshore agents used by universities to recruit hundreds of thousands of students, primarily from China and India.

On Friday, the ABC revealed an estimated $250 million in public funds was being paid in commissions each year by universities to these agents, in full knowledge that many are corrupt and dealt in fraudulent documents.

More often, these commissions are undisclosed to the public, and the students shepherded by agents to particular institutions.

Academics from across the country told the program there had been many positive aspects to the increased number of international students on campuses.

But they lamented the detrimental impact on academic rigour caused by having so many students with inadequate English language skills.

‘If you fail a first-year international student … that’s a loss of income’

Alex Barthel, a language consultant to universities and former director of the English language centre at the University of Technology Sydney, said language thresholds across the country were too low, putting untoward pressure on academics.

He said the pressure was being eased by ensuring most students passed and received their degree.

“There is increasingly soft-marking across the board,” he said on Monday night’s program.

“Sorry, I know that sounds crude, but that’s the reality.

“At a number of universities (there are) students passing courses, and (graduating) with a language proficiency that’s below that required in some cases…to enter the university.”

Staff forced to ‘dumb-down degrees’

Academics also reported a deterioration in the difficulty of course materials in some areas.

There are also a rising number of opportunities for students to either resubmit essays or sit what are sometimes called “supplementary exams”.

“There’s also been pressures on the academics … to make the courses simple enough so that the vast majority get through in a reasonably quick space of time,” Professor Frijters said.

“Hence you’ve effectively got to dumb down the degree. Now that’s happened definitely in the last couple of decades.”

Academics are confronted by a rising tide of student appeals for higher marks.

As an increasing portion of them are part-time casual teachers, working through a series of 12-week, single-semester contracts, there is a reluctance to fail students as teachers said the work required to manage appeals was effectively unpaid.

Plagiarism poses a similar problem.

The prosecution of students on charges of academic misconduct under university policies is so complex and time-consuming that many lecturers and tutors instead turn a blind eye to the problem.

ABC

Stay informed, daily
A FREE subscription to The New Daily arrives every morning and evening.
The New Daily is a trusted source of national news and information and is provided free for all Australians. Read our editorial charter
Copyright © 2024 The New Daily.
All rights reserved.