News National Who, us? Vic election not our fault: federal ministers

Who, us? Vic election not our fault: federal ministers

Tony Abbott Australian Prime Minister
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Senior federal government ministers have dismissed suggestions from their own side of politics that this year’s budget and a series of recent missteps cost the Victorian coalition government power.

After a horror week marked by confusion over the GP co-payment, unpopular cuts to the ABC and SBS, and the submarine gaffe of Defence Minister David Johnston, the federal coalition also denies that it is facing the same fate as the dumped Victorian coalition.

Liberal frontbencher Andrew Robb said the federal government’s woes were not responsible for the Victorian coalition’s woes, or that it faced a similar defeat in two years.

Labor rises to power: We won’t let you down
• John Cain: Daniel Andrews has won immense power
Paul Bongiorno: Abbott threw Napthine under a bus

“I don’t accept that we had a big influence,” the federal Victorian MP said on Sunday. “We will have a look at the implications but, clearly … this was a state election overwhelmingly fought on state issues.”

Federal Families Minister Kevin Andrews agreed, saying federal factors had been small, with polls showing a trend towards Labor three years ago.

“This election has been fought largely on state issues,” he said.

Denis Napthine Victorian Premier
Outgoing Victorian Premier Denis Napthine concedes defeat. Photo: AAP


But a clear split has emerged between federal Liberals and their state colleagues.

Victorian Liberals are pointing the finger squarely at Canberra for the debacle.

“Clearly the Commonwealth budget and the aftermath were a distraction,” Victoria’s outgoing Attorney General Robert Clark said on Sunday.

That was echoed by Deputy Premier Peter Ryan, who said the government struggled to “get the clear air to be able to sell our message”.

“It made it difficult at every turn to be able to get out of the blocks and that prevailed over a period of many, many months,” he said.

Daniel Andrews celebrates his election win with his father Rob. Photo: AAP
Daniel Andrews celebrates his election win with his father Rob. Photo: AAP

Former Victorian community services minister Mary Wooldridge said federal issues had been important, citing Labor’s use of Tony Abbott’s image in advertising and election day bunting.

The Victorian coalition had reportedly described the PM during the campaign as “box-office poison”.

No effect on 2016

Immigration Minister Scott Morrison distanced the next federal election from the Victorian poll. He said most marginal federal seats were in NSW and Queensland, where state coalition governments were likely to cruise to victory at elections next year.

Mr Morrison said the federal coalition had achieved a great deal in its first year, citing its success in scrapping the carbon and mining taxes, and stopping the boats.

However, he acknowledged it needed to work harder on “managing the politics”, in reference to the mixed messages on the $7 Medicare co-payment.

Federal parliamentary secretary Josh Frydenberg admitted the result was a wake-up call.

“The coalition strategists will look at the result more deeply over the coming days and take whatever lessons can be learned from it,” he told ABC television.

Shorten’s view

But federal Opposition Leader Bill Shorten was sure of who was to blame. He said it was clear the vote was a referendum on the prime minister and this year’s budget. Denis Napthine’s defeat has ripped up the political rulebook, he warned.

“(Tony Abbott) needs to not be in denial, not put his hands over his ears,” he told reporters in Melbourne.

“If Tony Abbott and his coalition team in Canberra with his unfair budget and broken promises are in denial about one of the factors in this election, well that would be a dreadful mistake,” Mr Shorten said in Melbourne.

Mr Shorten listed the GP co-payment, cuts to schools and hospitals and university deregulation as key issues.

“The conceived wisdom is first-term governments never lose. Daniel Andrews, a new Labor hero and a great premier for Victoria in the making, won and defeated a first-term coalition government,” he said.

“And I believe that some of the issues which contributed to it … were the fact that Tony Abbott’s brought down the most unfair, unpopular budget in living memory.”

– with AAP

View Comments