Doctors query advice on shorter COVID isolation

Professor Steve Robson is pushing for Australia to set up its own Centre for Disease Control. Photo: AAP
The president of the Australian Medical Association has warned the government about treating COVID-19 too similarly to other infectious diseases as mandatory isolation is cut to five days.
Professor Steve Robson says COVID-19 is a multi-system disease and couldnât be treated the same as the cold or flu.
âItâs a complete furphy to think that COVID is the same as the flu or cold and this is a dialogue weâre hearing around the place,â he said.
âWeâre seeing huge effects on the workforce from long COVID at the moment. So itâs very different to other infectious diseases, and it needs to be treated differently.â
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese says the move to reduce the isolation period down from seven days, except for workers in high-risk settings, was appropriate based on the health advice.
âThere arenât mandated requirements for the flu or for a range of other illnesses that people suffer from,â he said after Wednesdayâs national cabinet.
NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet says the nation needs to move away from public health orders, to a system where individual employees judge whether theyâre well enough to go to work.
Mr Perrottetâs comments follow a national cabinet decision on Wednesday to cut the COVID-19 isolation period from seven to five days.
âI do believe we need to move away from public health orders and we need to move to a place where if youâre sick you stay at home, and if youâre not sick you go to work,â he told the ABC on Thursday.
âUltimately, the point we need to get to is a less reliance on public health orders and a greater reliance on people respecting each other.â
But Prof Robson says the decision may be counter-intuitive to fixing workforce shortages.
âItâs got the potential to (increase cases),â he said.
âThe best information we have at the moment is up to a third of people, even if they feel well, and donât have any symptoms are potentially infectious.
âIf youâre making the decision to increase the workforce availability, decreasing pressures, youâve got to be very careful youâre not doing the exact opposite.â
But leading epidemiologist Catherine Bennett said it is unlikely there would be more infectious people in the community, given about one in three people know they have an infection and are isolating.
New data revealed 75 per cent of people had cleared the virus by seven days, Professor Bennett said.
The AMA president has also called on national cabinet to release the health advice underpinning the decision, saying the organisation wasnât consulted about the change.
âThe consultation going on at the moment, weâre not sure who itâs with,â he said.
âTheyâre not releasing that advice. We would love to see it. Most doctors around the country are scratching their heads on what this advice is.â
Under the changes, face masks on domestic flights will also become voluntary.
The reduction in isolation requirements for people who no longer have symptoms will come into effect from September 9.
The pandemic leave disaster payment will also move to cover the same five-day isolation period from that same date.
Leaders will meet in a fortnight to discuss the future of paid pandemic leave, which is due to wrap up at the end of this month.
Australia recorded 69 COVID-19 deaths on Wednesday, and more than 13,000 cases.
LATEST 24-HOUR COVID-19 DATA:
Victoria: 2645 cases, 18 deaths, 332 in hospital with 15 in ICU
NSW: 4701 cases, 23 deaths, 1756 in hospital with 36 in ICU
Queensland: 2033 new cases, 16 deaths, 308 in hospital, 11 in ICU
ACT: 199 new cases, one death, 92 in hospital, two in ICU
SA: 616Â new cases, three deaths, 107 in hospital, three in ICU
Tasmania: 216 cases, no deaths, 29 in hospital with two in ICU
NT: 123 new cases, no deaths, 20 in hospital, no one in ICU
WA: 1211 new cases, one death (on August 26), 217 in hospital with 5 in ICU








