News Coronavirus Ruby Princess inquiry chief’s questioning of crying health worker was ‘out of line’, PM says

Ruby Princess inquiry chief’s questioning of crying health worker was ‘out of line’, PM says

Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Prime Minister Scott Morrison says “aggressive” questioning that reduced a NSW Health employee to tears at the Ruby Princess inquiry was “out of line”.

Epidemiologist Kelly-Anne Ressler, who had direct contact with the cruise ship before it docked in Sydney, was questioned for hours on Tuesday on the department’s precautionary procedures.

At one stage she broke down while admitting it was “unsatisfactory” to have tested more people on board for influenza than COVID-19, despite signs of illness.

“If we could do it again it would be very different,” Ms Ressler said through tears.

Commissioner Bret Walker SC asked Ms Ressler why he should not conclude there had been a “reprehensible failure” from the state’s health department.

  • See a live stream of the Ruby Princess inquiry here

On Wednesday, Mr Morrison told radio station 2GB he found the evidence distressing and public health workers were “doing their best”.

“They have been working day and night for months and months and months,” Mr Morrison said.

“I know we’ve got to get to the truth on this sort of stuff, but my first blush on that one – and that’s not to call into question the independence of the royal commission or anything like that – but I found that a bit out of line.”

Mr Morrison said Ms Ressler should be thanked for her work.

“To see her reduced to that, under that sort of aggressive line of questioning, you’ve got to get the balance right on this one and I would hope Mr Walker would reflect on that.”

The inquiry is probing the decisions made around the disembarkation of the ship’s 2700 passengers in March, despite the fact test results for COVID-19 were still yet to be returned.

The inquiry heard a senior Carnival Australia director, Paul Mifsud, reassured the Ports Authority that the Ruby Princess was “not a COVID ship” just hours before it docked.

Port Authority manager Robert Rybanic said he was told it was “business as usual”, despite swabs having been taken for COVID-19 and the test results pending.

The Prime Minister said Commissioner Bret Walker SC needed to reflect on his questioning. Photo: ABC

“They have to submit a declaration on arrival and one of the questions is, is there any COVID cases on board the ship,” Mr Rybanic said.

“How could anyone know that?” Mr Walker replied.

The commissioner asked whether Mr Rybanic would use the term “not a COVID ship” for a vessel with suspected but not confirmed cases.

“I generally wouldn’t use that terminology at all,” Mr Rybanic said.

On Wednesday, Carnival Australia port agent Dobrila Tokovic gave evidence that she found out the day before the ship arrived NSW Health officials would not board the vessel when it docked.

She said that was “in some ways” surprising.

“Just from my own experience, having 100 people unwell for a duration of a cruise would not stand out as a significant number,” she said.

Counsel assisting the inquiry Richard Beasley SC replied: “But that experience is almost entirely in a pre-COVID world.”

The Ruby Princess has been linked to nearly 700 coronavirus cases and at least 21 deaths and is Australia’s largest single source of infection.

The ship was given a rating of “low risk” by NSW Health based on a log of onboard illness that was 18 hours old by the time the vessel docked, the inquiry has heard.

Had the log been updated, the percentage of sick passengers and crew would have pushed it into a higher risk category and triggered more NSW Health intervention, including onboard assessments.

The inquiry is due to report by mid-August.

NSW Police are conducting a separate, criminal investigation into the circumstances surrounding the Ruby Princess’s arrival in Sydney.