Prime Minister Boris Johnson has suffered a heavy defeat in parliament’s upper chamber over proposed laws that would allow him to breach Britain’s EU exit treaty – a plan that has been criticised by US president elect Joe Biden.
The Internal Market Bill is designed to protect trade between Britain’s four nations after Brexit.
It contains clauses ministers say are needed to protect Northern Ireland’s delicate status as part of the United Kingdom, but would also break international law in a “specific and limited” way.
The House of Lords voted to strip those clauses from the bill in a series of defeats for the ruling Conservative Party.
Prime Minister Boris Johnson of Britain is in the final phases of trying to negotiate a post-Brexit trade agreement with the European Union. The complex challenge is now more urgent with the defeat of his ally and ideological mate, President Trump.https://t.co/kov4xyLyAP
— The New York Times (@nytimes) November 10, 2020
The government does not have a majority in the Lords and even some high-profile Conservative members opposed the clauses.
“The government should see sense, accept the removal of these offending clauses, and start to rebuild our international reputation,” said Angela Smith, the opposition Labour Party’s leader in the Lords.
Far from backing down, however, the government said it would retable the contentious clauses when the bill returns to the House of Commons, where it had previously passed by 340 votes to 256.
“We’ve been consistently clear that the clauses represent a legal safety net to protect the integrity of the UK’s internal market and the huge gains of the (Northern Ireland) peace process,” a spokeswoman said.
The massive Gvt defeat on the Internal Market Bill last night should lead them to drop it. If it comes back to the Lords with the illegal clauses reinserted, we will reject it again – and again if necessary.
Ex-PM joins condemnation of markets bill https://t.co/sXn6i4Ft1V
— Dick Newby (@RichardNewby3) November 10, 2020
The publication of the bill in September provoked criticism with some saying it would wreck Britain’s international standing.
Mr Biden tweeted on September 16 that anything which endangered the peace accord between the Irish republic and Northern Ireland would threaten Anglo-American trade.
Mr Johnson says the clauses are there to act as a safety net in case ongoing negotiations with the EU fail to work out how goods can flow between Britain, the British province of Northern Ireland, and across the open border with EU member Ireland.
Many instead saw the bill as a negotiating gambit to win concessions from the EU in trade negotiations.
Brussels has launched legal action against Britain over the proposals.
“EU cannot ratify a new deal while UK is legislating to break a previous agreement,” Irish foreign minister Simon Coveney said on Twitter. “Trust & Good Faith Matters.”
The final wording of the bill has to be agreed by both houses, and typically the unelected Lords does not permanently block laws supported by the directly elected House of Commons.
However, the clauses may no longer be needed if talks with the EU on how to make the Irish border work are successful.