Finance Your Super UniSuper, IOOF and AustralianSuper top superannuation leaderboard

UniSuper, IOOF and AustralianSuper top superannuation leaderboard

Australians could save more than $200,000 in retirement by switching to a low-fee fund, according to Stockspot. Photo: TND
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

HESTA, UniSuper and AustralianSuper are the superannuation funds with the best performing ‘growth’ funds, according to an annual review by investment adviser Stockspot.

The 2020 Fat Cat Funds report – which judges the 100 largest super funds based on their after-fee returns over five years – found all three funds delivered annual average returns above 7.4 per cent during that timeframe.

And in the overall rankings, it ranked UniSuper and AustralianSuper as the first and third best superannuation funds, with 174-year-old investment company IOOF coming in second.

AMP and the formerly ANZ-backed OnePath, on the other hand, represented more than half of the 40 poorly performing “fat cat” funds, with AMP crowned the worst-performing provider across all four categories.

And AMP Capital’s Dynamic Markets Fund made history as the first balanced fund to deliver a negative return of 2.2 per cent.

Sustainable investing surges

Stockspot founder and CEO Chris Brycki said most Australians “blindly trust” their superannuation funds without considering how investment strategies or fees affect long-term returns.

He told The New Daily that funds with ethical or sustainable strategies were particularly noteworthy this year.

When I first started writing this research in 2013, I hoped a lot of people would realise they’re in bad funds or move away from those that charged extortionate fees for poorer results,” Mr Brycki said.

“But the introduction of MySuper has not fixed the lack of competition, with some funds clearly still operating inefficiently by increasing administration fees without achieving any economies of scale.

“However, [sustainable] funds, who tend to exclude fossil fuel companies from their portfolio, ended up performing really well as oil prices and consequently stocks [did] quite badly over the last five years.”

Stockspot’s analysis found the average “fit cat” growth fund charged 1.10 per cent in fees, compared to the “fat cat” average of 2.08 per cent.

According to Mr Brycki, 30-year-olds who switch from a fund charging two per cent fees to one charging 0.5 to one per cent would net an additional $200,000 to $250,000 upon retirement.

Centaur Financial Services principal adviser Hugh Robertson told The New Daily the scant attention Australians pay to their superannuation has allowed providers to hike their fees without much backlash.

But making a judgement call solely based on how much a fund charges in fees is ill-advised, he said.

You need to look at the level of risk they’re taking and you need to see if they are invested in liquid or illiquid assets, with unlisted assets a real danger spot people need to be aware of,” Mr Robertson said.

Mr Robertson said the biggest risks facing members who are considering selling out and switching funds are losing much-needed insurance and being exposed to Capital Gains Tax.

For example, a customer with a $160,000 balance could expect to pay around $8000 in tax if they switched funds, he said.

So it’s important to get a holistic overview of a fund’s performance and how it aligns with short- and long-term investment goals before committing.

“If you have a 10-year outlook and you’re going to save $5000 a year in fees, it would be worth your while,” Mr Robertson said.

“And if you’re close to retirement, [your fund] might have a super pension CGT transfer, which means you can transfer to pension phase without paying any tax,” Mr Robertson said.

Tips before making a switch

  • Understand your own fund first
  • Find out if you have insurance tied to your fund
  • Understand the fund’s asset allocation.
  • Do a proper appraisal before switching (by either sitting down with a professional or conducting due diligence).

Got a tip? Contact the author at

The New Daily is owned by Industry Super Holdings