Finance Your Super The multibillion-dollar cost of the super guarantee freeze revealed

The multibillion-dollar cost of the super guarantee freeze revealed

Two stacks of coins with plants growing from the top of each.
Freezing increases to the super guarantee has already cost workers $38 billion. Photo: Getty
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Australian workers have missed out on almost $40 billion since the brakes were placed on increases to the employer superannuation guarantee (SG). 

Since super guarantee contributions were frozen at 9.5 per cent in 2015, workers have missed out on $38 billion, modelling by Industry Super Australia (ISA) shows.

The modelling follows the creation of a new calculator th enables super fund members to predict how much they stand to lose if the guarantee remains at its current level, instead of increasing to the originally planned 12 per cent.

A button that links to ISA's calculator.

Using the average Australian income of $62,000 and the Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia’s estimated super balances for someone aged 30 to 34, the calculator shows someone aged 30 today would be about $70,800 worse off at retirement than they would if the guarantee lifted to 12 per cent.

ISA chief executive Bernie Dean said the numbers “show that Australian workers cannot afford another delay” to the planned SG increases.

Industry Super Australia modelling.
How a 12 per cent super guarantee affects balances. Source: Industry Super Australia

“Every Australian deserves the right to a financially secure retirement, and keeping the freeze on the super guarantee will only make that harder,” Mr Dean said.

“A 30-year-old earning $80,000 will be robbed of close to $90,000 in super by the time they reach retirement if the super guarantee remains frozen at 9.5 per cent. This is not good enough.”

A state-by-state breakdown shows that New South Wales alone stands to lose more than $12 billion.

A table showing Industry Super modelling.
How much super each state stands to lose. Source: Industry Super Australia

Raising the stakes

Currently, the SG is legislated to lift from July 2021, with an increase of 0.5 per cent each year for the following five years. But shadow treasurer Chris Bowen has confirmed a federal Labor government would stick to  those increases.

“Let me make it clear that the Labor Party does not regard a 9.5 per cent super guarantee as providing adequacy,” Mr Bowen said.

“We will brook no further delay to the legislated timetable.”

However, those planned increases have become an increasingly contentious point in the lead up to the May federal election, with independent think tank, the Grattan Institute, repeatedly calling for proposed raises to be scrapped entirely.

“The super guarantee forces people to save while they are working, so they have more to spend in retirement. But there is no magic pudding when it comes to superannuation,” the Grattan Institute wrote in its Commonwealth Orange Book 2019.

“Higher compulsory super contributions are ultimately funded by lower wages, which means lower living standards for workers today.”

Modelling conducted by the Grattan Institute shows working-age Australians can already expect their post-retirement income will be “substantial” relative to what they earned before leaving the workforce.

Instead of increasing the super guarantee, the institute said further changes to the retirement system should focus on reforming “unfair” super tax arrangements, reducing super fees, making the age pension more accessible, and increasing the age requirements for accessing super to “from 60 to at least 65, if not 70”.

“These reforms would have an enormous impact on retirement incomes,” the Orange Book report said.

A table showing when the super guarantee will lift, and by how much.
Guaranteed super contributions are scheduled to start increasing from July 2021.

The Grattan Institute has also called on the next federal government to launch an inquiry into superannuation to assess its performance – a suggestion also put forward by the Productivity Commission in May.

The super industry has roundly panned those recommendations.

The New Daily is owned by Industry Super Holdings

View Comments