$2312 for burnt toast: Residents slugged with huge false alarm fees


The MFB has invoiced owners in one apartment block more than $6000 in callout fees related to food-related false alarms. Photo: TND
Imagine being fined more than $2300 for burning toast.
Then imagine having to pay such an exorbitant fine multiple times within a matter of months.
Apartment owners in Melbourneâs inner north know how frustrating it is to shell out thousands of dollars for such simple, everyday mistakes.
Over the past 12 months, the Metropolitan Fire Brigade has invoiced owners living in one apartment block more than $6000 in callout fees related to false alarms triggered by burnt food or smoke from cooking.
Because the building is covered in flammable cladding, an expert panel comprising members of Moreland City Council, the Victorian Building Authority and MFB ordered owners in July 2018 to directly link their fire alarms to the MFBâs system as part of an Emergency Building Order.
The recommendation, which means firefighters automatically respond as soon as an alarm is triggered, was one of many put forward by the panel to keep occupants safe.
But the alarms are so sensitive that even the whiff of burnt toast is enough to trigger them â and every time that happens, firefighters rush out to their building and often charge owners up to $2312 for doing so.
Owners say itâs yet another blow in their battle with cladding.
âIâm scared to cook toast unless Iâm standing over it,â one owner, who declined to be named, told The New Daily.
âIf we get a hint of smoke while cooking, we have to open all the windows, [but] itâs the middle of winter.â
The owner doesnât blame the MFB, but believes all the fines should be waived â partly because the alarms are so sensitive, and partly because living in a building with flammable cladding has already put owners under undue stress.
âI donât blame the MFB, theyâve had a hell of a year. But the situation weâre in is equally untenable,â the owner said.
My biggest worry is people covering up or disabling their alarms because theyâre afraid of being billed.â
In letters seen by The New Daily, the buildingâs Owners Corporation has repeatedly warned owners to minimise false alarms by:
- Using the range hood when cooking, ensuring it is vented to the outside, and cleaning it regularly
- Closing the bathroom door when showering as âsteam has been known to activate the alarmâ
- Closing the laundry door when drying clothes for the same reason
- Never leaving the cooking unattended.
The Owners Corporation has also written to the MFB asking it to reassess âfuture incidents on an individual basisâ, warning that the MFBâs callout fees âmay result in residents blocking up the sensors which could be an extremely dangerous situationâ.
It has even paid contractors more than $2000 to intensively clean all the smoke detectors in the common areas to minimise false alarms.
The New Daily understands the owners have been asked to install additional heat detection systems as part of a separate building notice.
Once this has happened, they will have the option of installing a system that gives owners 30 seconds to override false alarms before the MFB is alerted, which should limit callouts related to false alarms.
The New Daily asked the MFB whether it thought the fines were fair given the circumstances.
A spokesperson confirmed to The New Daily that the MFB had responded to the building eight times in the past six months and sent invoices related to four incidents.
But they also said the Owners Corporation had been given multiple opportunities to respond and provided late submissions to all four invoices sent, with two final notices later issued.

The 2017 Grenfell tower fire in London caused 72 deaths, and led to widespread international concerns about flammable cladding. Photo: AAP
âInvoices were issued to the siteâs Owners Corporation in relation to four separate incidents involving burnt food or smoke from cooking at this address since January 2020,â they said.
âIn some circumstances where an invoice has been issued, MFB may make exemptions on compassionate or other grounds, and fee recipients are encouraged to contact us to discuss their options.â
Firefighters have responded to 13 false alarms at the building over the past 12 months and waived fees on some occasions.
The New Daily also asked the VBA if it thought the fines were fair given the circumstances, and whether it had considered covering the costs of the fines given they were related to a recommendation included in an Emergency Builder Order.
A VBA spokesperson said: âMaintaining the safety of residents and building occupants is our highest priority.â
Know something we donât? Contact the author at [email protected].








