Entertainment TV Sonia Kruger’s anti-Muslim comment ‘illogical’: expert

Sonia Kruger’s anti-Muslim comment ‘illogical’: expert

Kruger said she had many "peaceful" Muslim friends. Photo: Getty
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Race relations experts say media personality Sonia Kruger’s call to ban Muslim migration to Australia, made on prime time TV, could contribute to a rise in xenophobic attacks in Australia.

On Monday, Kruger told panellists on Channel Nine’s Today show she agreed with a recent column by News Corp’s Andrew Bolt linking the Nice attacks with France’s Muslim population.

“Personally I think Andrew Bolt has a point here,” Kruger said.

“I have a lot of very good friends who are Muslim, who are peace loving, who are beautiful people – but there are fanatics,” she said.

She added that terrorist attacks were almost unheard of in Japan and cited its relatively low Muslim population.

Experts, including Kruger’s former university professor, told The New Daily that Kruger’s comments were more likely to breed radicalism than prevent it.

Host Lisa Wilkinson asked Kruger to clarify that she was echoing Donald Trump’s calls for an all-out ban on Muslim immigrants.

“Yes … for the safety of our citizens here, I think it’s important,” Kruger said.

Dr Andrew Jakubowicz, University of Technology Sydney (UTS) professor and race relations expert, said he taught Kruger at university and lamented that “Logic 101” was not part of the course.

Watch Sonia Kruger’s Today comments below:

‘I have a lot of Muslim friends’

Following the inevitable social media backlash, Kruger stood by the comments on Twitter, while Australia’s Race Discrimination Commissioner Tim Soutphommasane called for the public to speak out against “stereotyping that breeds hate”.

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull shut down the comments.

Australia has a non-discriminatory immigration program … for many, many years, and that is not going to change,” he said during a press conference.

sonia kruger muslim immigration
Muslim advocate Mariam Veiszadeh offered to meet Kruger for a coffee. Photo: ABC

Dr Jakubowicz said the presenter’s argument lacked logic.

“Yes, the more people you have in a country, the more chance of homicidal maniacs, but the vast majority aren’t homicidal maniacs,” he told The New Daily.

Two per cent, or 476,300 of Australians, identified as Muslim in the 2011 Census.

Dr Jakubowicz said despite the climate of fear, Australia needed to debate national security without abandoning democratic values.

“This isn’t about political correctness,” he said, arguing that Kruger’s comments were more likely to cause radicalisation than prevent it.

“If you’re an ISIS strategist you’d think, ‘What do I need to really piss off more Muslim people? I really need some rednecks to get stuck into them’.

“And then I need no one to stand up and say there’s something wrong with that.”

Dr Jakubowicz sardonically suggested Australia would save more lives by banning the immigration of young men – who are statistically more likely to kill their partners than Muslims are to commit terrorist acts.

Christina Ho, senior lecturer in social and political sciences at UTS, said comments such as Kruger’s made racism more socially acceptable.

“Racism is absolutely on the increase and there’s lot of evidence to show Muslim Australians are reporting increases in attacks and abuse,” she said.

sonia kruger muslim immigration
Migration to Australia for 2014–15 shows the government’s “skills-based” selectivity. Photo: Australian Government

Ms Ho said Australia’s current migration system – which focusses on skills rather than race – was actually studied by her academic colleagues in Japan as an example of a multicultural success story.

sonia kruger muslim immigration
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson has called for a ban on Muslim immigration also. Photo: Getty

“For a country with such a level of multiculturalism, we’ve basically had no terrorism,” she said.

“France has an immigration policy of assimilation, whereas we have a policy of celebrating differences.”

‘Let’s meet up, Sonia’

Lawyer, columnist and Muslim advocate Mariam Veiszadeh told The New Daily she had reached out to Kruger following the comments.

“I’d like to invite Sonia out to have a coffee and discuss her concerns,” she said.

“Let’s have fact-based conversations free from hysteria.”

Veiszadeh, who came to Australia as an Afghani Muslim refugee, recently launched the website Fact Check One Nation.

Run by Australian Muslims, the site aims to “illuminate the substance and veracity” of One Nation and Pauline Hanson’s policy claims about Islam.

View Comments