Entertainment Celebrity Vanity Fair Mexico criticised for ‘tone-deaf’ Melania Trump cover

Vanity Fair Mexico criticised for ‘tone-deaf’ Melania Trump cover

Melania Trump eats diamond necklaces on the cover of Vanity Fair Mexico. Photo: Vanity Fair
Twitter Facebook Reddit Pinterest Email

Mexicans and Americans alike are outraged United States First Lady Melania Trump is Vanity Fair Mexico‘s latest cover star, given President Donald Trump’s ongoing efforts to “build a wall” between the US and Mexico.

The cover of the magazine’s February issue shows Mrs Trump pretending to eat a plate of diamond necklaces like spaghetti, with the cover line: “Her family background, the tactics to deal with her husband and how she plans to become the new Jackie Kennedy.”

Prominent Mexicans have expressed anger over the decision, describing it as “out of touch” and “insensitive” given current tensions between the United States and Mexico.

“It’s a lack of sensitivity on the part of the publisher,” Mexican author Guadalupe Loaeza told The Guardian. “I started reading this and I couldn’t finish. I didn’t want to know anything about the wife of our country’s No 1 enemy.”

Mexican political analyst Denise Dresser took to Twitter to comment on the cover, sarcastically writing it was a “great example of sensitivity, empathy, patriotism and editorial intelligence”.

Many felt the image of Mrs Trump dining on opulent jewellery was “tasteless” and provided a stark contrast to Mexico’s socioeconomic climate.

Some commenters even called for a boycott of the magazine.

Mexican LGBT activist Alex Orué criticised Vanity Fair for “deciding to normalise the Trumps with your readers,” despite the magazine having the opportunity to “highlight the cultural and social life of Mexico”.

However, Vanity Fair Mexico’s editor-in-chief Lourdes Garcon responded to Mr Orué, saying the magazine’s intention was “quite the opposite”.

“I encourage you to read the text,” she wrote.

The profile in question first ran in US GQ magazine in April 2016 and was written by Russian-American journalist Julia Ioffe.

The original piece featured comment from people who knew Mrs Trump when she was living in Slovenia who described her as “not especially clever”.

After it was first published, Ms Ioffe became the target of vitriolic anti-Semitic threats from Mr Trump’s supporters who felt the article was too critical of Mrs Trump.

Melania is also shown holding a plastic cup of diamonds.
Melania is also shown holding a plastic cup of diamonds. Photo: Vanity Fair Mexico

The cover comes after Mexico’s president Enrique Peña Nieto cancelled a scheduled meeting with Mr Trump on Thursday.

President Nieto made the bold move in response to Mr Trump signing executive orders pertaining to the construction of a border wall and the increased deportation of undocumented Mexican immigrants.

There has also been debate over which country should pay for the wall, with the White House claiming Mr Trump would consider imposing a 20 per cent tax on Mexican imports to cover the cost of the southern wall.

However, the two leaders managed to proceed with bilateral negotiations in a phone conversation on Friday (US time).

In a joint statement, Presidents Trump and Nieto said: “With respect to payment for the border wall, both presidents recognised their clear and very public differences in their stances on this very sensitive issue, and agreed to solve these differences as part of a comprehensive discussion of all aspects of the bilateral relationship.”

The statement from Mr Nieto’s office also added: “The presidents also agreed for now not to speak publicly about this controversial issue.”

View Comments