NBN is rolling out inferior technology in poorer areas: report

Australiaâs most affluent suburbs are more often gaining access to superior fibre technology under the National Broadband Network (NBN) rollout than areas of socio-economic disadvantage, according to new analysis.
Researchers at the NHMRC Centre for Research Excellence in the Social Determinants of Health Equity have found a âdefinite trendâ: the poorer the socio-economic conditions, the less frequently homes and businesses are receiving fibre technology.
Instead, poorer areas are much more likely to have what many experts have termed âinferiorâ technologies, including wireless, HFC or satellite.
Only 29 per cent of homes in the lowest socio-economic tier had been granted fibre technology â either fibre-to-the-node (FTTN) or fibre-to-the-premises (FTTP).
Australian National Universityâs Dr Ashley Schram, who led the analysis, said that if the âconcerningâ trend persists it could lead to a âdigital divideâ, with those socio-economically disadvantaged also being positioned as having a technological disadvantage.
Further, those living in poorer suburbs would be required to foot the bill for an upgrade to superior technology to access faster internet speeds.
âThe NBN was meant to address equitable access to the internet for all Australians regardless of their socio-economic backgrounds. Looking at this trend, it doesnât seem to be achieving that,â Dr Schram said.
âIf when the NBN rollout is complete we are still seeing the same picture, I would be very concerned. The pattern suggests itâs entrenching inequitable access to better digital infrastructure in higher socio-economic areas.
âIf areas already facing disadvantage need to pay for infrastructure upgrades to access the same level of technology in higher socio-economic areas in 10Â or 20 yearsâ time, this will have contributed to a deepening digital divide in Australia.â
She said that Australians already facing geographical isolation and greater disadvantage may âbenefit mostâ from increasingly reliable internet connections to access online education, health and other government services.
âThe NBN presented an opportunity to narrow the digital divide and enhance equitable access to internet services in Australia, providing better access to online business opportunities, or healthcare and education services, particularly in rural and regional areas,â Dr Schram said.
Dr Schram noted that NBN Co declined to provide a complete dataset distinguishing between FTTN and FTTP in areas, categorising both under the âfibreâ category.
She said further analysis would greatly benefit from more transparency from NBN in this regard.
âWe will require more transparency from the NBN to fully understand the factors driving this trend and what exactly determines which areas receive a particular type of technology,â she said.
âThe NBN infrastructure isnât complete and the NBN company still has time to start considering the equity impacts of the rollout, whether intended or not.â
An NBN spokeswoman said it would be rolling out broadband access to every Australian home and business âregardless of location or any other socio-economic profilingâ.
She added: âSuggestions that NBNÂ is selectively rolling out the network according to socio-economic profiling is incorrect.â








